Introduction
Today, I’ll talk about shocking news (for me) that I read about Cholamandalam Investment. In the finance sector, it is a very reputable company.
Cholamandalam Investment is a part of a massive 125-year-old Murugappa Group. These are the same people behind brands like BSA bicycles and Parry sugar.
However, a new investigation by Cobrapost has just brought to light some very strange things happening behind the scenes. It is a huge story with lots of details in it.
In this post, I’ll try to summarize the whole thing for you.
The Rs. 10,000 Crore Family Web
Imagine you have a big piggy bank, let’s name it CIFCL (Cholamandalam Investment & Finance Company Ltd).
It is filled with money from your neighbors and the bank.
Instead of just using that money to help people buy cars or houses, imagine you started moving over Rs. 10,000 crore into other small companies owned by your own family members.
Cobrapost found that over the last decade, CIFCL and its partners moved this massive amount of money through a “web” of related companies.
So what is the problem with it? There would not have been a problem had they declared the movement of money to the public/authorities.
But, they only told the public about roughly Rs. 2,161 crore of it. The rest was hidden away from the regular reports that investors use to see if a company is healthy or not.
The Mystery of the Rs. 25,000 Crore Cash Pile
There is something even weirder in this story.
Most big finance companies use digital transfers for almost everything today. But the Cobrapost investigation found that CIFCL deposited around Rs. 25,000 crore in cash into more than a dozen different banks over the last six years.
Why is this a red flag for a company like Cholamandalam Investment?
Usually, when a company collects that much cash, it means the people they are lending money to aren’t paying back their loans through the regular, digital way.
This makes experts wonder if the company’s loans are actually in much worse shape than they are telling the public.
Where Did the Money Go?
Cobrapost tracked the money to two main “middleman” companies: Chola Business Services (CBSL) and Murugappa Management Services.
- CBSL received over Rs. 4,103 crore from CIFCL for “staffing services.”
- Murugappa Management Services was used to move around Rs. 675 crore.
Once the money reached these companies, much of it was paid out to Murugappa family members and top bosses as salaries or “professional fees.”
For example, some family members and senior managers received tens of crores each.
Questionable “Donations” and Payouts
The investigation also found CIFCL paying huge fees to the very agencies meant to check if they are doing a good job (like their auditors and credit rating firms).
This creates a “conflict of interest,” like paying a teacher to grade the homework of her students.
They even found money going to sports bodies like the BCCI and religious groups like the Isha Foundation, often hidden under “work contracts” instead of being listed as simple donations.
Conclusion
When a company handles public money, it is supposed to be transparent.
Cobrapost argues that while the family owners got very rich from these secret deals, the regular shareholders (the everyday people who own shares of the company) got a “raw deal” because that money should have stayed inside the company to make it look stronger.
It looks like a giant game of “hide the money.”
But now that the floodlights are on. There are a lot of questions that the Murugappa Group hasn’t fully answered yet.
What do the shareholders do now?
At this stage, what shareholders can demand is full transparency.
The Cobrapost story suggests that public shareholders received only a “raw deal.”
While the Murugappa family and top bosses were enriched by nearly Rs. 10,000 crore through a web of related party transactions, everyday investors only received standard dividends.
If these massive funds had been kept within the company instead of being diverted as fees and salaries, the value for common shareholders would have increased by approximately Rs. 5,000 crore.
Essentially, the owners profited from hidden deals while regular shareholders were left with far lower returns.
Shareholders can do the following:
- Formally question the Board regarding the Rs. 25,000 crore in cash deposits. This may be concealing the true scale of Non-Performing Assets (NPAs) if applicable.
- Also, push for a rigorous review of the Audit Committee’s oversight concerning the Rs. 10,262 crore in transactions where only Rs. 2,161 crore were officially disclosed as Related Party Transactions (RPTs). Hence, demanding an independent audit will be a wise decision. It will likely eliminate the potential conflicts of interest identified among current auditors and rating agencies.
- Ultimately, shareholders should also advocate for regulatory intervention by SEBI and the RBI to ensure disclosure integrity.
Please wait for my next article. You can also subscribe to my newsletters and get notifications of a new post right into your inbox.
