Understanding the Impact of Multiple Health Claims on Insurance Premiums

Let’s explore the impact of multiple health claims on insurance premiums. Discover how past claims history can influence your policy costs. Gain insights into managing your health insurance expenses more efficiently. Learn to navigate the intricacies of insurance and make informed decisions for a secure financial future.

Health insurance plays a crucial role in safeguarding the financial well-being of individuals and families. It provides a safety net against the soaring costs of medical treatments and hospitalization. In a country like India, where healthcare expenses continue to escalate, having a comprehensive health insurance policy is becoming a necessity. It ensures access to quality healthcare without undue financial strain.

The demand for health insurance coverage has witnessed a substantial upsurge in recent years. It is caused by lifestyle-related diseases and unforeseen medical emergencies. As a result, people are becoming more dependent on these policies to manage their hospitalization expenses.

The utility of a health insurance policy is unquestionable. But in this article what we’ll discuss is a hidden aspect of these health covers. As a policyholder, we must know how to deal with it in advance.

Allow me to start by telling you the facts of a real case.

Impact of multiple health claims on insurance premiums - Thumbnail

#1. The Facts

A person is anguished by the steep rise (40%) in his health insurance premium. His health insurance premium becomes due in September of each year. In July’23, he got a pre-intimation letter from Tata Aig that, for the forthcoming year, his annual premium will increase by more than 40%.

The letter cited the reason for the premium rise to the migration of the policy. The wording of the letter said, “We request you migrate your existing policy before the expiry date to continue enjoying your existing benefits.

During the previous year (2022), the person made several health claims (about 10 nos), during a span of 10 months. The total claim amount in the policy tenure of 2022 was 22% of the total claim amount. All the claims were honored by Tata Aig swiftly and the person was more than happy with his policy.

But to his surprise, the insurance company decided to increase the premium by more than 40%. The person did some self-study and found that multiple health claims in a narrow span of time may have caused the premium increase.

But it is not counter-intuitive to raise the premium due to health claims. The person has paid the premiums since last so many years that he gets health coverage when needed. But if the claims will cause an increase in the premium, it sounds irrational, right?

This article aims to unravel the complexities of health insurance premiums, with a specific focus on the impact of multiple health claims. By analyzing the above case and examining the factors that insurance companies consider when adjusting premiums.

Our aim is to provide insights into the correlation between claims history and premium adjustments. Furthermore, we’ll also learn how to avoid the impact of claims on the annual premium.

#2. Understanding Health Insurance Premiums

Insurers utilize a meticulous process to calculate premiums. They take various factors into account to arrive at a fair and sustainable amount. The calculation of health insurance premiums is a dynamic process that relies on statistical analysis, actuarial science, and risk assessment.

Insurers collect premiums from a pool of policyholders. The collected money enables them to pay for the medical expenses incurred by those requiring healthcare services. This system is founded on the concept of shared risk. Here, the burden of individual medical costs is distributed among a large group, making healthcare accessible and affordable.

Key factors influencing premium amounts include:

  1. Age: Age plays a significant role in premium calculation. It is because the likelihood of health-related issues tends to increase with age. Younger policyholders usually pay lower premiums, whereas older individuals might have higher premiums.
  2. Medical History: A policyholder’s medical history is scrutinized to gauge the risk of potential future claims. Pre-existing conditions or a history of health issues can result in higher premiums or specific exclusions.
  3. Coverage Type: The extent of coverage desired by a policyholder impacts the premium. Comprehensive plans with wider coverage typically come with higher premiums.
  4. Geographic Location: Medical costs can vary significantly based on the region, affecting premium amounts. For example, medical expenses in a Tier-1 city will be higher than in a Tier-2 city.
  5. Policy Duration: Longer policy durations may offer benefits such as lower premiums, providing more extended coverage stability.
  6. Lifestyle Habits: Certain lifestyle choices like smoking or excessive alcohol consumption may lead to higher premiums due to increased health risks.
  7. Co-payment: Opting for higher co-payment can lead to reduced premiums. As policyholders agree to share a portion of the expenses, lower premiums are possible this way.

These are the seven primary factors, that influence the premium of a health insurance policy. So, for an existing policyholder, the age can cause a jump in the premium over time. This is kind of understandable.

But premium hikes due to multiple claims are beyond comprehension. Such a step defeats the purpose of the health coverage itself.

#3. The Significance of Claims History

In the realm of health insurance, the claims history of policyholders carries weight in determining insurance premiums. The claims history represents a comprehensive record of the policyholder’s past utilization of healthcare services. It reveals valuable insights into their health risks and potential future claims.

The relevance of claims history lies in its ability to provide insurers with a clear picture of the policyholder’s health condition and utilization patterns. A policyholder with a history of multiple claims may be deemed to pose a higher risk to the insurance company. Insurers consider the frequency, severity, and type of claims made when evaluating the policyholder’s risk profile. These in turn influence the premium amount.

Hence, making multiple claims within a narrow span of time can have an impact on future premium amounts. Insurers interpret frequent claims as a potential indicator of a policyholder’s susceptibility to illnesses increasing the likelihood of future claims. Consequently, the insurer may adjust the premium to account for the perceived higher risk.

“Health insurance premiums are based on risk. If you have multiple health claims, your insurer will assume that you are more likely to make claims in the future, and they will charge you a higher premium to reflect this.”

#4. Managing Health Insurance Costs

For policyholders who have experienced multiple health claims, managing premium adjustments can be a task. It is essential to strike a balance between comprehensive coverage and cost considerations. The idea is to ensure continued protection without undue financial strain. What policyholders can do to manage their health insurance costs?

Here are some practical tips and strategies:

  1. Review Policy Coverage: The current coverage can be adjusted to lower the premium. Evaluate if all existing add-ons and riders are still relevant. Eliminating unnecessary benefits can help reduce premiums.
  2. Opt for Higher Deductibles (Copayment): Selecting a higher deductible can lower the premium. The deductible is the amount the policyholder pays as its own contribution during the settlement of the final bill. Though it is essential to ensure that the deductible remains affordable in the event of an emergency.
  3. Having Multiple Health Policies: If one insurer does not like multiple claims, then as a policyholder we should consider keeping more than one policy. This was it is possible to distribute the claims between say two companies.

By implementing these practical tips a policyholders can navigate the challenges of managing health insurance costs after multiple claims.

There is always an option of switching the policy from our existing service provider to a new service provider. If the premium escalation is too high, the first step should be to discuss the current insurance company for a possible premium lowering. Parallely, you may want to shop around for a new policy with a different insurer. Some insurers may be more willing to offer you a lower premium.

“If you are concerned about a premium increase, talk to your insurer. They may be able to offer you some options to help you keep your premium low.”

#5. How to Negotiate with The Current Health Insurance Provider

Suppose you are on a telephone call your my current health insurance provider. What you can tell them so that they will lower your health insurance premium?

First of all, it is essential to be polite, confident and prepared. Here’s a step-by-step guide on what to say during the conversation:

  1. State Your Purpose: Clearly state the reason for your call – to discuss the possibility of lowering your health insurance premium.
  2. Highlight Loyalty: Mention how long you have been a policyholder with their company. Give them the impression that you value your relationship with them. Emphasize that you have been making regular premium payments.
  3. Claims History: Mention why your claim has spiked in recent times.
  4. Healthy Lifestyle: If applicable, talk about any positive lifestyle changes you (your family) made. Give examples like quitting smoking, adopting healthier habits, or engaging in regular exercise. Explain that these changes may contribute to better health and reduced risk.
  5. Policy Review: Discuss your current policy and mention any optional coverages or riders that you may be willing to remove to lower the premium. Take their advice to ensure that essential coverage is maintained.
  6. Compare with Competitors: Politely mention that you’ve been exploring other health insurance options and have found some competitive premiums elsewhere. Let them know you would prefer to stay with their company.
  7. Ask for Suggestions: Request their advice on how you can lower the premium while retaining necessary coverage. Ask if they have any discounts or cost-saving options available.
  8. Thank Them: Regardless of the outcome. Thank the representative for their time and consideration. Be respectful, even if they are unable to lower the premium as much as you hoped.

Remember, the decision to lower your health insurance premium ultimately rests with the insurance company only. They may have specific guidelines and factors affecting premium adjustments. Be prepared to consider alternative options or policies if necessary. Always be polite and patient during the conversation to maintain a positive relationship with your insurer.

#6. Switching The Health Insurance Policy

What care must be taken to switch the health insurance policy to a new health insurance provider?

Switching health insurance policies to a new provider requires careful consideration and attention to detail. Here are some essential steps and precautions:

  1. Research and Compare Plans: Compare coverage benefits, premium costs, network hospitals, and claim settlement ratios. Check customer reviews about the new insurance provider.
  2. Policy Overlaps: Ensure that there is no overlap between your current policy and the new policy to avoid paying for redundant coverage. Plan the switch to align with the end date of your existing policy.
  3. Waiting Periods: Be aware of any waiting periods that may apply to the new policy, especially for pre-existing conditions. Understand the waiting period requirements for specific treatments or ailments before making the switch.
  4. Medical Underwriting: If you have pre-existing conditions or a history of claims, check if the new insurer requires medical underwriting. Disclose all relevant health information truthfully to avoid claim rejection later.
  5. Portability Option: If you wish to switch without losing continuity benefits (like waiting periods and no-claim bonus), inquire if your current insurer offers a portability option. Porting allows you to transfer your policy to a new insurer without losing certain benefits.
  6. Cancellation Procedure: Follow the proper cancellation procedure with your current insurer. Provide written notice and ensure that you receive a confirmation of policy cancellation.

Before making the final switch, consult with an insurance advisor or the customer support team of the new insurer. You can ask and seek clarifications for even the smallest bits like network hospitals, claim procedures, etc. Do not make the switch till you have all your questions answered.


We’ve shed light on essential aspects of health insurance premiums. We’ve seen the impact of multiple health claims on insurance premiums. We explored how insurers calculate premiums based on various factors, including claims history, and how making multiple claims within a short period can influence future premium amounts.

To effectively manage health insurance expenses, policyholders should evaluate their coverage needs. They can compromise on co-payments etc to lower the annual premium amount.

Understanding the intricacies of health insurance empowers individuals to strike the right balance between comprehensive coverage and affordability.

“A premium increase due to multiple health claims is like a tax on being sick. It may sound unfair, but it’s the way the system works.”


Why did my health insurance premium increase after making multiple claims?

Health insurance premiums may rise when policyholders make multiple claims within a short period. Insurance companies consider claims history to assess the policyholder’s risk profile. Frequent claims indicate a higher likelihood of future claims, leading to premium adjustments.

Can I prevent premium hikes due to multiple claims?

Consider strategies like opting for higher deductibles, and maintaining a healthy lifestyle. One can also explore multiple health covers to distribute claims. It will mitigate the concentration of risk on a single insurer.

Will the premium increase affect my existing policy benefits?

A: Premium adjustments generally do not impact existing policy benefits. Your coverage and policy features remain unchanged.

How can I find affordable health insurance coverage after multiple claims?

To find affordable coverage, compare health insurance plans from different insurers. Taking price quotes from multiple health insurance providers is the way forward.

Should I switch insurers to avoid premium increases?

Switching insurers is an option. But it may not guarantee lower premiums solely based on claims history. Consider the overall benefits, network hospitals, and claim settlement record of the new insurer before making a decision.

Suggested Reading:

Stock analysis is complicated, use our Stock Engine to analyze selected 1,300+ number stocks.

The Stock Engine will give its first impression about its stocks. Then it goes deeper and calculate its intrinsic value and the overall score. The Stock Engine makes it easier to interpret the fundamentals of stocks even for untrained investors.



Hi. I’m Mani, I’m an Engineering graduate who in pursuit of financial independence, has converted into a full time blogger. After working in the corporate world for almost 16+ years, I bid it adieu....read more

Disclaimer: The information provided in my articles and products are for informational purposes only and should not be considered as financial or investment advice. Read more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *